For this CVPR I did two passes of review. On the first one, I made at-a-glance decision. On the second pass, I (hopefully) did justice to the paper. The interesting bit is the transition matrix in decisions. The rows are the "at-a-glance" decision, the columns are the final one.

. Reject Weak reject Borderline Weak accept Accept . Reject 3 . Weak reject 1 . Borderline 1 . Weak accept 1 2 1 . Accept .